Crust. 5 I loved the flavor and texture. This is what I want in this kind of crust firm.
Filling. 4. Good flavor and texture a little rich for me. I had it cold the next day which is best like you said.
Overall 4. Topping could use a little more flavor like vanilla?
Crust: 5 Like a yummy cookie.
Filling: 5 Sweet
Overall: 5 I don’t think I am going to share my slice with my husband.
All I want for my birthday is this pie!
Crust: 4 Crust had good texture. Soft but not soggy.
Filling: 4 Filling was great and I really like the banana with it all. I ate it all! I liked the Grey texture of the filling with the banana and whip cream. Great!
Overall: 4 Mmmm really good!!!
Crust: 4 little hard but good
Filling: 5 with banana compote
It may be impossible to make crust easier to cut but it would be nice otherwise great.
Okay, here’s my critique…
Crust: 3 The crust on the other hand was uneven in texture. The bottom part of it was so thin that there’s nothing left to hold the filling when you slice and scoop it. It tasted real good crust for that particular pie.3
Filling: 4 The filling tasted good, didn’t have that separated taste of the two ingredients.
Overall: 3.5 The pie didn’t get that much syrupy like in the bottom. If the bottom of the crust is even with side I’ll dive into it with 4****
Okay I have a cold 🤧 so my tasters may be a bit off; if you have cold and your body craves chicken soup, this just may not be the pie for you.
Crust: 2 – I can’t put my finger on it, maybe it’s a salty flavor.
Filling: 3 The toffee and the bananas are carrying all of the sweetness, and the toffee is “over the top” sweet. The whipped cream is unsweetened, and thank goodness; because the pie would have been too sweet overall.
Overall flavor gets a 2 – the constituents are so different that bite by bite I got too much of one or another, and never a blend of all the flavors.
The dense sweet crust and caramel layer was great; would have made a great holiday square cookie. The pudding layer was too subtle for me to detect the flavor of bananas and it lost its shape (cut too soon?) And the whipped cream layer seemed like it needed vanilla and sugar.
Crust: 4 Graham cracker with slight zest. One of my favorites.
Filling: 4 This was hard because I like the toffee part but would of liked more bananas. So the filling lacked something that would give it the ultimate 5 rating.
Overall:4 Unique flavor with the sweetest flavor at the bottom of the pie radiating upward to the least sweetest.