Crust: 4 Very crunchy and crumbly, but bonus points for being chocolate.
Filling: 5 Loved it! The peanut butter was light and fluffy but I appreciated the use of crunchy peanut butter to give it some texture. It had a strong enough flavor without feeling like I was just eating straight peanut butter. The chocolate on top had a great texture and flavor.
Overall: 5 This is what a pie should taste like. I still can’t get over how good it was.
Filling: 5 The right kind for peanut butter filling great flavor and texture.
Chocolate topping was not too thick . you could cut it
Ok this was a favorite!!! Loved the cookie crust, great filling. I thought it was the perfect texture and balance of peanut butter. The chocolate on top was great. Even keeping it in the fridge it was not hard to cut into. Peanuts on top was great. Best pie yet. Rated: 5!!!
Crust: 3.5 just average
Overall 5 The peanut butter pie was excellent.
Crust: 5 Great chocolate crust.
Filling: 4 Creamy rich filling.
My only complaint is that peanut butter is so rich I had to have more than one go at it. Just what a pie should be!
Crust: 3 Chocolate graham cracker crust.
Filling: 4 Very good pie filling smooth peanut butter cheesecake – 4
Overall: 4 Very good pie overall.
Super high marks because this presents well and will appeal to most people. Fudge topping
smooth, soft consistency. Peanut butter filling mousse light and surprisingly subtle flavor. Oreo crust (?) perfect for this pie. Nice delineated layers.
Crust: 5 It’s chocolate, do I have to say more?
Filling: 5 Usually peanut butter filling is very bland, almost lack flavor, but this is perfect.
Topping: 5 Soft fudge type of chocolate that melts in your mouth but holds it’s shape on the pie.
Overall: 5 I think I “finally” found the perfect chocolate pie! (believe me I have eaten a few)